Read more

One body? Bishops to continue debate over Eucharistic document at fall assembly


It won’t be on the agenda, but it will dominate the meeting anyway. When the U.S. bishops gather for their fall general assembly, the big issue before them will be unity. And not unity with somebody else but among themselves.

What threatens to divide them are conflicting views on the Church’s preeminent sacrament of unity, the Eucharist — specifically, who can worthily receive holy Communion and who cannot.

That isn’t new. At their Nov. 15-18 meeting in Baltimore, the bishops will resume a  debate that exploded publicly at their general assembly in June. Then, as now, the question dividing them was whether to say Catholic politicians who support abortion — a group notably including President Joe Biden — should be refused Communion unless they change their minds and repent.

Some bishops think the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops should say that, others are convinced it shouldn’t.

The focal point in Baltimore will be a statement on the “meaning of the Eucharist in the life of the Church” prepared by the USCCB Committee on Doctrine, chaired by Bishop Kevin C. Rhoades of Fort Wayne-South Bend, Indiana. After a tense two-hour debate last June, the bishops voted 168-55 with six abstentions to move ahead on a draft.

But one result of that debate, together with a series of closed-door regional discussions since then, is likely to be a document with no sharp edges that would be offensive to pro-abortion politicians or anybody else. Instead, the statement is expected to stress the positive and avoid singling out politicians for criticism or suggesting that abortion is the only measure of worthiness to receive the sacrament. It will also reaffirm that the decision in particular cases is up to individual bishops rather than USCCB.

Almost certainly, though, the meeting’s main point of interest will be what the statement on the Eucharist says or doesn’t say about prominent Catholic pro-choicers like Biden. Since June, the president and his administration have continued their high-visibility support for abortion. Most recently, that included removing a ban on giving family planning funds to abortion providers, a policy that cost Planned Parenthood, the nation’s largest abortion provider, nearly $60 million yearly.

In September, Cardinal Wilton D. Gregory of Washington, who opposes denying Communion to Biden, nevertheless challenged the president on a key point of Catholic doctrine. The president had said human life doesn’t begin at conception, but the cardinal reminded a National Press Club audience that the Church teaches that it does; he added that Biden was “not demonstrating Catholic teaching” in saying differently. 

But by far the most significant abortion-related development on the Church’s side in recent months was Pope Francis’ in-flight news conference, also in September, while returning to Rome from a visit to Hungary and Slovakia. Asked about the debate in the U.S. over giving Communion to pro-abortion politicians, the pope gave a typically freewheeling reply open to various interpretations.

Declining to comment specifically on events in America, he nevertheless took a notably strong stand against abortion, calling it “homicide” and saying that for the Church to accept it “would be like accepting daily murder.”

At the same time, however, he insisted that bishops should adopt a “pastoral” approach on Communion for pro-choicers and “not go around condemning.”

Finally, though, he dismissed as “a hypothetical” the conclusion that a pastoral approach necessarily meant giving Communion. “The pastor knows what he has to do at all times, but as a shepherd,” he concluded.

Having had five months to think things over, the bishops are likely to seek to soften the sometimes confrontational tone that marked their debate in June, threatening to shatter the appearance of collegial consensus much prized by the hierarchy. Students of the episcopal conference know bishops have been divided before on issues, to say nothing of conflicting styles and personalities. But it would be hard to recall a previous occasion when they disagreed quite so publicly as they do now.

In that context, many people will be waiting to see what line particular members of the hierarchy with a special stake in the outcome will take during the debate in Baltimore. 

That includes, on one side, Archbishop Joseph F. Naumann of Kansas City, Kansas, chairman of USCCB’s pro-life committee, and Archbishop Salvatore J. Cordileone of San Francisco, who has clashed publicly with Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, a pro-abortion Catholic from his archdiocese, and on the other side Cardinal Blase J. Cupich of Chicago and Bishop Robert W. McElroy of San Diego, both of whom have strongly opposed denying Communion. 

Also closely watched will be what USCCB president Archbishop José H. Gomez of Los Angeles says in his opening remarks. As much as anyone, after all, Archbishop Gomez got this particular ball rolling last January with an Inauguration Day statement sharply critical of the newly elected Catholic president’s support for abortion.

It hardly needs saying, too, that Pope Francis’ views will carry important weight with the bishops. If he has said any more than he did on the plane in September, it has been said privately and out of sight. Bishops and everybody else will therefore be listening carefully for any further indications in the talk traditionally delivered at the start of a bishops’ meeting by Archbishop Christophe Pierre, the papal Nuncio to the United States. 

This article comes to you from Our Sunday Visitor courtesy of your parish or diocese.


Catholic News & Perspective

Provides information on the Church, the nation and the world from OSV, America's most popular and trusted national Catholic news source


As Christmas nears, remember to prepare — and rejoice

Wednesday, December 8, 2021
By: Scott Warden There is so much to love about our Catholic faith, but one thing I’m appreciating more as I grow older is the Church’s... Read More

Supreme Court hears arguments as to why it must right its past abortion wrongs

Monday, December 6, 2021
By: Richard W. Garnett It is a basic rule of court-watching and law-punditry that one should not assume that justices’ questions, or their... Read More

Opening the word: The soul seeks the Word

Friday, December 3, 2021
By: Father Joshua J. Whitfield St. Bernard of Clairvaux, in one of his many sermons on the Song of Songs, said it best, I think: “The soul... Read More

See the Nativity through the eyes of ‘The Chosen’ this Advent

Wednesday, December 1, 2021
By:Lisa Hendey “People must know.” Those iconic words spoken in the pilot episode of the worldwide streaming giant “The... Read More

The elephant in the room of the bishops’ assembly

Monday, November 29, 2021
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion A very large elephant was standing in the middle of the room when the American Catholic bishops met in Baltimore in... Read More

Opening the Word: Advent reminds us we are pilgrims

Friday, November 26, 2021
By: Catherine Cavadini “The days are coming, says the Lord, when I will fulfill the promise I made to the house of Israel and Judah”... Read More

Indianapolis to host national Eucharistic Congress in 2024

Wednesday, November 24, 2021
By:  Michael R. Heinlein The U.S. bishops have voted to host the National Eucharistic Congress, slated for July 2024, in Indianapolis. To... Read More

Bishops approve plans for three-year National Eucharistic Revival

Monday, November 22, 2021
By: Carol Zimmermann BALTIMORE (CNS) — The U.S. bishops’ focus on the significance of the Eucharist in the life of the Church... Read More

Opening the Word: Jesus, the king

Friday, November 19, 2021
By: Timothy P. O'Malley Dear readers, this is my last “Opening the Word” column for Our Sunday Visitor. I’m so grateful to have... Read More

Let’s not make gratitude a (forgotten?) trend

Wednesday, November 17, 2021
By: Gretchen R. Crowe Do you remember a time, in the not too distant past, when social media during November was almost synonymous with public... Read More